Magazine advert first draft

When doing my planning for my magazine advert, I made several different layouts in order to see which design was most effective. I then took forward my two favourite layouts and asked ten people that link in with my target audience which one they prefer. This layout was the favourite as 7/10 people preferred it, I am happy with this result as I also prefer this layout too. I think it is more effective as the image is slightly bigger than my other designs, it is therefore slightly more simplistic, which shouldn't be seen as a negative thing as the minimal style could be seen as quite up to date and fashionable. I have therefore made my first draft of my magazine advert, by including my chosen font and using the quotes and ratings that I want. Although this still needs a lot of work, I am still quite happy with how it is coming along.